Successful Judgement in Labour Appeal Court
Proud and privileged to have been involved in this successful Judgement in the Labour Appeal Court for our client, Legal Aid South Africa.
Legal Aid South Africa v Jansen (CA3/2019) [2020] ZALAC 37 (21 July 2020)
Proud and privileged to have been involved in this successful Judgement in the Labour Appeal Court for our client, Legal Aid South Africa whom had appealed against the judgment of the Labour Court which had held that Mr Jansen’s dismissal was automatically unfair in terms of section 187(1)(f) of the Labour Relations Act and that he had been unfairly discriminated against in terms of section 6 of the Employment Equity Act . The Labour Appeal Court held that depression is a prevalent illness, employers have a duty to deal with it sympathetically and should investigate it fully and consider reasonable accommodation and alternatives short of dismissal. In addition, where depression may account in part for an employee’s misconduct, depending on the circumstances and the nature of the misconduct, dismissal may not be appropriate. However, for the reasons explained in the full Judgement copied herein, there was no proper claim of substantive unfairness and the Labour Court had erred in finding unfair discrimination and that the dismissal was automatically unfair. The appeal was therefore upheld.
*Disclaimer: This advisory should not be interpreted as legal advice.
Author: Michele Engela
Related News
When Is a Restraint of Trade Reasonable?
A recent Labour Court judgment illustrates when a restraint of trade may be unreasonable and why employers must carefully consider its scope, the interests requiring protection and any undertakings offered by a departing employee.
A Landmark Victory for Cross-Border Marriages: The End of the Husband’s Domicile Rule in South African Marriage Law
The Western Cape High Court has abolished the outdated husband’s domicile rule for cross-border marriages, replacing it with a gender-neutral framework that promotes equality, dignity and legal certainty for international couples.
Enter At Your Own Risk – Disclaimer Notices and Exclusion of Liability
“Enter At Your Own Risk” signs do not provide unlimited legal protection. Learn when disclaimer notices are enforceable and how the Consumer Protection Act limits liability.